I asked and you delivered. Some interesting choices here, so let's get crackin'...
Re: Jack and Will: "It's their humor, I'm telling you - smart humor is massively sexy! Even though both of them play the goofball, they are both very smart about it, and I love that."
Joel McHale (The Soup)
Vincent D'Onofrio (Law & Order: Criminal Intent)
Says Mie, "You pick which one is the shocker."
Jon Krasinski (The Office)
Jared Leto (the My So-Called Life version, not the current version).
Shocker: Kid Rock
Keifer Sutherland x 5.
Her shocker is Buck Owens.
Hayden Panettiere (Heroes)
Britney (circa 2000)
Christina Ricci (circa 1998)
Alyssa Milano (circa 1992)
Lisa Rinna: "I don't know why. Must be something about her grotesquely modified face." (I think I know why.)
Shocker = Jeff Goldblum
The Movie Guru:
Katherine Heigl (Grey's Anatomy)
Isla Fisher (Wedding Crashers)
Shocker = Bernadette Peters
Carter Oosterhouse: "The builder guy that used to be on Trading Spaces then was on the Amy Grant Wishes show. He's also made several guest appearances on The Today Show."
Orlando Bloom: "Tiny but sexy"
Ralph Fiennes in The English Patient
Julian Sands in Room With A View and Boxing Helena
"My list is weird."
Samantha Brown from Travel Channel
Jenna Fischer (The Office)
Anna Kournikova (Yeah, still)
Tina Fey - SNL & 30 Rock
Shocker - Sandra Bernhard
Scarlett Johansson: "Honey. Glazed. Donuts."
Kate Beckinsale: "Can she act? Who cares."
Gina Gershon - "45 never looked so good."
Jessica Alba - "That caboose should be against the law."
Zuleikha Robinson - "If you saw her in HBO’s Rome, you know why."
Kim Basinger: "Older than me, still looks great. Knows how to make Alec Baldwin insane. Beautiful..."
Cillian Murphy (I think he's just dreamy, excuse me while I gush...)
Christian Bale (do you think I like guys with accents? ;) )
Catherine McCormack (Braveheart)
Shocker = The MILF-tastic Jean Smart
Adrian Grenier (Entourage)
Shocker = John C. Reilly ("he makes me laugh")
"Mine are kind of boring and predictable."
Shocker: Wendy Crewson ("She's one of those supporting actors you always see in movies but no one knows who she is. She's older but I've always liked her.) (great choice, billbo. I like Wendy too)